Welcome to the Candlelite Inn, Located on Beautiful Shelter Island, NY. The Candlelite Inn is a 181 year old Victorian, situated on one and a half acres in the center of Shelter Island. Recently redecorated, The Candlelite Inn has 5 guest rooms with private baths, central air conditioning, television in the common living room and offers a continental breakfast.

All of our guest rooms have queen size pillow topped Kingsdown beds and high quality 600 thread count bedding for your comfort. We have a beautiful wraparound porch to enjoy your morning coffee or just to relax at the end of the day.

Perfect for a romantic weekend getaway,The Honeymoon cottage is a separate 350 square foot cottage where you will enjoy complete privacy. The cottage boasts a King size sleigh bed, a six foot double whirlpool, 4 foot shower, television, antique furniture and air conditioning.  The Inn has high speed wireless internet and all rooms have blow dryers and charging stations.
Continental Breakfast is also included.

The Candlelite Inn is within short walking distance to Vine Street Cafe which offers fine dining for those with a discerning palate with indoor and outdoor seating. The Mashomack Nature Conservancy is also within walking distance from the Candlelite Inn. Mashomack is a natural area of nearly 2,100 acres edged by 10 miles of coastline where hikers of all levels can traverse marked trails ranging from one to twelve miles. You might want to see Shelter Island from the water and many guests take advantage of the local kayak rental. For those less adventurous, you can visit The Marika's Antique Shop, check out one of our many pristine beaches or just curl up on the front porch with a good book.

For those who are wine lovers there are many vineyards on both the North and South Fork.

We are unable to accommodate small children or pets at the Candlelite Inn and we are smoke free.  For those who do smoke, you can enjoy the use of the front porch.

For reservation information please call (631) 749-0676 or (631) 834-7578
Check-in is after 3:00 p.m. and check-out is by 11:00 a.m.


Bed & Breakfast

The Candlelite Inn

  1. -Bed & Breakfast

  2. -187 year old Victorian

  3. -Modern Look


Shelter Island, NY

With advance notice & extra charge can schedule:

  1. -Hair services available in JBS the on-premise salon Highlighting, Color, Hair design and Styling