Welcome to the Candlelite Inn.

3 South Ferry Road
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Phone/Fax: (631) 749-0676
Phone: (631) 834-7578 • candleliteinn@gmail.com

Located on Beautiful Shelter Island, NY. The Candlelite Inn is a 190 year old Victorian, situated on one and a half acres in the center of Shelter Island. Recently redecorated, The Candlelite Inn has 5 guest rooms with private baths, central air conditioning, television in the common living room and offers a continental breakfast.

All of our guest rooms have queen size pillow topped beds and high quality thread count bedding for your comfort. We have a beautiful wraparound porch to enjoy your morning coffee or just to relax at the end of the day.

 

View our Rooms

Honeymoon Cottage

What people are saying.

 

“Amazing place to stay! Rooms are very cozy and the location is so convenient for basically anything on the island. I stayed in Honeymoon cottage and it was a perfect romantic getaway. Highly recommending this place!!!.”

— Relja Salh

“Was an awesome experience, even though I didn't get a chance to get my hair colored, I could see the professional hairdresser was top notch!! Maybe next time.”

— Norma Lockhart